Find Greats Jobs is an independent job search aggregator. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Security Jobs Compared: SIA, Retail and Defence Roles
Compare 10 UK security vacancies by setting, shift pattern, SIA requirements and published pay, from £15.50 hourly roles to MOD work.
Quick Picks
Best published pay: Mitie Area Security Officer, with a listed range of £15,000–£22,000 annually.
Best for retail security: Retail Security Guard (SIA), because the role is clearly aimed at shop-floor protection.
Best for defence-site work: MGS Security Officer Shift Worker, based at Lympstone and linked to the Ministry of Defence Guard Service.
Security work is not one job. A retail guard deals with theft and customer-facing incidents; an MOD guard works within a more controlled site environment; an area officer may cover several posts. The listings below are compared on the details actually published, not promises that the source pages do not support.
Published pay and established employers
Only one listing in this set gives a clear annual range, while another source exposes hourly rates from related security vacancies. That gap matters: you cannot compare a salary role with an hourly role until you know the hours, overtime and shift allowance. The published figures are useful signals, not a full earnings guarantee.
Area Security Officer
Mitie is the most transparent listing on pay: JobLeads shows £15,000–£22,000 for a full-time Area Security Officer in Leicester Forest East. The role covers DWP sites, so expect public-sector premises and formal procedures rather than a quiet reception post. The annual range looks modest beside the £15.50 hourly rate shown for a related Mitie vacancy on SimplyHired, which is exactly why applicants should confirm contracted hours before applying. Best for someone with an SIA licence who can handle site coverage and wants a named national employer.
Security Officer
This Mitie Security Officer listing is less useful on paper because the supplied page does not reveal pay, hours or location details. The employer name still gives it more context than an anonymous advert, but do not assume it matches the Area Security Officer terms above. Ask about the site, rota, breaks and whether travel between locations is paid. Best for an applicant who wants to explore Mitie roles but will not apply until the missing conditions are confirmed.
Security Officer
GuardWatch Security UK Limited lists a Security Officer role in Okehampton, but the supplied page extract does not show pay, shift pattern or licence requirements. That makes it harder to rank against Mitie on value, yet the local employer may suit someone who wants one site rather than area coverage. Treat the missing salary as a question to ask before travelling to an interview. Best for an Okehampton-area applicant who already has security experience and values a local posting.
Security Officer SIA
The SIA Fixed Term Security Officer role is the clearest short-term route in the group, but Jooble's supplied extract does not publish pay, location or end date. Fixed-term work can get you earning sooner, though it gives less security than a permanent contract and may not justify a long commute. Confirm the exact contract length, renewal prospects and shift times before accepting. Best for an SIA-licensed worker who needs a defined assignment rather than a permanent post.
Pay transparency drops sharply after the Mitie listing. The practical lesson is simple: use the published £15.50 hourly comparison on SimplyHired as a prompt to ask every other employer for an hourly equivalent, not as proof that every vacancy pays the same.
Site type changes the job
Retail, concierge and defence security can share the same SIA foundation while feeling completely different during a shift. Customer contact, incident pressure, access control and uniform expectations all change with the site.
Ministry of Defence Guard Service Security Officer
The MGS Ministry of Defence Guard Service role in Lympstone is the most specialised setting here. The title confirms shift work, so applicants should expect rota discipline and the possibility of nights, weekends or early starts; the extract does not publish the actual pattern or pay. Defence-site work may appeal to people who prefer controlled access points over retail confrontation, but screening and site rules can be stricter. Best for a security professional comfortable with shift work, formal procedures and a defence environment.
Retail Security Guard
Retail Security Guard (SIA) is more direct than the generic officer listings: the setting is retail and the SIA requirement is in the title. That usually means visible floor patrols, theft prevention and regular interaction with store staff and shoppers, although the supplied Jooble extract does not confirm pay or hours. Choose it for a customer-facing shift, not for a quiet monitoring post. Best for an SIA holder who stays calm around shop-floor incidents and wants a clearly defined retail setting.
Retail Security Officer
The Retail Security Officer listing gives one useful market clue: SimplyHired shows related Mitie security supervisor work at £15.50 an hour and Bardwood supervisor work at £16.50 an hour in the same results area. Those are supervisor vacancies, not proof of this officer role's pay, but they show why progression can matter in retail security. The role itself needs closer checking for employer, rota and licence details. Best for someone entering or continuing retail security who wants a route toward supervisory work.
Concierge Security Officer
Concierge/Security Officer combines front-of-house duties with protection work, which changes the skill balance from pure patrols. The supplied Indeed page does not show pay, employer, hours or required qualifications, so the title is doing most of the work. Expect presentation, communication and visitor handling to matter alongside alertness, but confirm whether the post is residential, commercial or hospitality-based. Best for a confident communicator who prefers reception-style contact over constant retail patrols.
Part Time Retail Security Officer
Part-time Retail Security Officer is the clearest schedule-led listing in the set. The part-time label may suit someone balancing study, caring responsibilities or another job, but Indeed's supplied extract does not reveal the weekly hours, pay or rota. Do not assume part-time means predictable; retail cover often includes evenings and weekends. Best for a licensed guard who needs fewer hours and can work around store opening patterns.
Which security job should you apply for?
Apply for Mitie Area Security Officer if you already hold the relevant SIA licence, can work full time and want the only listing here with a published annual pay range. Pick MGS Lympstone if defence-site work and shift patterns suit you better than retail contact, but ask about screening, rota and allowances first.
Retail Security Guard (SIA) fits an applicant who is comfortable speaking with shoppers and responding to suspected theft. The Part Time Retail Security Officer is the better route for someone who needs reduced hours, while Concierge/Security Officer suits a polished communicator who prefers visitor-facing duties.
For Okehampton applicants, GuardWatch Security UK Limited is worth checking because the location is explicit, but the missing pay and schedule need confirming. The fixed-term SIA role makes sense when speed and a defined contract matter more than long-term certainty. The remaining Indeed and LinkedIn listings should be treated as leads until the employer reveals the basic terms.
Check the original advert before applying: listings can close or change. StudySmarter's job board, Jooble and Indeed host the source listings used here. Find Greats Jobs connects you with job listings from across the web. We are not an employer and do not represent any of the companies listed.
Security work is one route into wider site operations, facilities and production environments. For a related comparison of plant-based roles, shifts and skills, read Production Jobs Compared: Shifts, Skills and Locations.